Showing posts with label Meandering. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Meandering. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 29, 2026

Mutated, dismembered, afflicted, & doomed

Before he met his tragic end, Vørpé the Magic-User suffered just about every negative non-death setback a PC in my campaign could experience. 

I use death and dismemberment rules similar to this and a mutation table similar to probably every other one you've seen. I have a boutique list of curses and diseases—which for practical purposes are treated almost the same in the world of Nevelorn—and for consequences of a cosmic variety I have a rough outline of dooms (for chaotic characters) and damnations (for their lawful counterparts). 

Vørpé, starting life as a gene freak, entered the game with two mutations:

Furnace gut. Your stomach radiates light as a candle. You only gain sustenance from wood, coal, oil, and alcohol.

Stench. A distinct, horrible smell follows you wherever you go. -2 to Charisma; hiding is difficult.

He only became more freaky over the course of his adventures. Tampering with an alchemical engine left him with 

Horns. Come out of your forehead. Deal d3 damage if used as a weapon. Headgear must be specially made. Roll d6 or choose the appearance: 1. Ram 2. Bull 3. Unicorn 4. Devil 5. Antlers 6. Beetle

(he rolled Devil).

And when he drank the melted remains of a mutant frog, his lower extremities morphed into 

Bird legs. Great for perching. Cannot wear boots.

Later, an unfortunately well-aimed hobgoblin firebomb left one of those legs charred and worthless. 

A failed save to avoid an acid trap almost turned Vørpé into a steaming puddle. As he lay melting on the dungeon floor, he called out to whatever chaotic god or overfiend was listening to spare his life. The odds were slim, but due to his history of erratic behavior and physical alterations, he attracted the attention of the Faceless God Juiblex, demon lord of ooze and mutation. Vørpé suffered a vision of the Great Glistener's infinite roiling non-countenance and was saved. His body reconstituted itself with a fifth mutation (Serpent neck. Long and slithery. Good for peeping around corners and creeping people out.), but this favor marked him for doom: when next he would be reduced to 0 hp, he was to erupt in a torrent of green slime and become one with Juiblex, taking whoever was nearby along with him.

Vørpé met an untimely end in an appropriately anticlimactic manner: standing in the blast radius of the first and only fireball he fired from a new magic wand. His death offered an important lesson about the risks of using magic items willy-nilly before identifying them, a lesson dutifully recorded by the party note-taker and ignored repeatedly from then on. Fortunately the rest of the party was spared, as the only other creature in the blast radius was the undead monstrosity Vørpé intended to hit, and double fortunately the fire immediately incinerated the green slime which would otherwise have caused one or more major problems for the surviving party members. 

6d6 points of regret

Vørpé's passing was tragic and his player was bummed, though to his credit he took it in good spirit. The party held a funeral for Vørpé back in town and a new draft horse was named in his honor. Out of the game, the players and I refilled our drinks and toasted to the fallen PC. 

***

What makes death and dismemberment, mutations, and lingering afflictions work so well in OSR games are that they make tangible a character's foibles. If magic items and precious treasure serve as records of a PC's triumphs, a missing leg and a tentacle arm serve as records of their defeats, which are often as entertaining if not more than victory.

The obstacles imposed by a missing leg become an engaging aspect of the character. Even when one can't do something as well because however many sessions ago they took too much damage or failed a save, there's satisfaction in knowing your guy has been through more than most and has the scars to prove it. A movement penalty sounds unambiguously annoying on paper, but every time it becomes relevant it's a fun little reminder of a nail-biting escapade.

There's nothing wrong with death at 0 (trve kvlt), but you don't get these kinds of characters when there's little ground between linear progress and total death. Higher level PCs have died in our campaign, but none are remembered like Vørpé.

Thursday, April 30, 2026

DM tip: write fiction

I started writing little scenes about the locations keyed in my hex map and it's transformed my game for the better.

The player-facing map


While preparing my campaign's hex map, I decided separately after a series of strange synchronicities—things said to me in passing, posts surfacing on the timeline, the rediscovery of a book on writing I was gifted but never read—I ought to write more fiction. 

I don’t think of myself as a "writer" but I can write passably if the weather's fair and I put in the hours. Still, there's much room to improve and I wish to exert myself creatively. Most of the writing I do is nonfiction; whenever I write fiction, regardless of how good the end result is, the process is about as elegant as a child mashing his toys into the floor.


I decided three hand-written pages a day, because that’s what my friend who’s doing Artist’s Way (speaking of synchronicity) recommends. I’ve never read the book but I hear it’s very useful. No finished stories, just scenes and dialogue. We're sketching, not painting.


Seeking subject matter I figured: why not write about the hexcrawl? What would a scene of adventures coming to this town here on the corner of the map look like? 


And so from my pen flowed a tale of wanderers sharing thoughts as they pass through unfamiliar streets. They make their way to a tavern where the barkeeper tells a story about an old festival no one celebrates anymore. 


Now, questions of quality aside: the piece was fun to write and it gave me time and space to explore each idea in the hex map more thoroughly. Externalizing thoughts as a story switches your brain into a sort of generative state, where you suddenly start producing the "next" idea as you write out the last one. I had only the briefest notion of a festival, but as the story unwound I arrived at what it celebrated, why it stopped, and how to bring it back. I would have missed this had I just written a list of bullet-point list of facts about the town, as is my typical prep method. Not only that, but I found language to describe the town and what the players see—a sort of first-draft for putting images to words, which saves me from groping about at the table for the rights words to verbally convey the images in my brain.


I did this approximately every day for two weeks, writing scenes relating to a dozen keyed hexes. The characters, conflicts, and locations within the hexcrawl are more vivid to me than anything else I have ever created for my games. Writing the scenes makes each hex more true; the stories expand the palette of language and ideas I work with as I prep and run the game. This depth of understanding far exceeds what is necessary to run a good campaign, but once you develop it, everything from generating NPCs on the fly to describing the frog demon's splattering boils becomes easier.


Even without a hexcrawl to write about, writing fiction works many of the same muscles you use to run a game. You inhabit different characters, create vast landscapes filled with compelling details, and leverage descriptive language to evoke emotion.  

I do not suggest you write fiction based on your campaign if you're not doing it for the sake of writing. It takes a substantial amount of time, you won’t use most of what you write, and it could lead to a maladaptive overprotectiveness of your setting. This is writing practice, not campaign prep.


But, if you do wish to improve your writing, and are looking for subject matter, consider: you are an RPG person. You think about adventure games and related topics all the time, even when you're not trying to. You can channel all that energy into your games, or discussions about games, or god forbid discussions about discussions about games, but you can also use it to propel progress in a different craft and help both passions flourish. 


Writing is like fitness. It’s healthy. It gives you a better handle on your thoughts, improves your insight, and deepens your appreciation of the richness of life. Not to mention if you get good at it, you may create something beautiful.


Tuesday, March 31, 2026

Work, Shortcuts, and Shortcomings

My marble visage wrinkles with an Ozymandian sneer when I read the countless posts advocating the disposal of this rule or that procedure because they are, and I'm trying my best to be charitable, "not fun." Perhaps even "tedious." People who toss out exactness in favor of abstraction without a second thought.

To those who feel that counting grid squares and tracking resources and encounters separately represent some overwhelming cognitive task, and instead choose to handwave them with abstract movement and overloaded encounter dice: Do you complain a cast-iron pan lacks teflon? Do you curse that a fine linen shirt must be pressed? Do you bemoan that a Stradivarius need be tuned? 

"No one really tracks rest turns," they convince themselves. "No one likes beancounting." As though a dice telling you whether a torch exhausts is more enlightened than writing a note six rows down your notepage. No, this proletarian note-taking is too much work. These people prefer plastic dice, probably because they're brightly colored and don't leave graphite on your fingers.

I have, for a long time now, been a lover of old school D&D. Every night I pray at my alter of B and X, Moldvay and Cook the red and blue onis who sit on my shoulders as I run. Before a session I arm myself with the Commentaries of St. Gavin, the OSE Rules Tome, which I have wrapped in black gaffers tape as a sign of reverence and because I dislike the front cover illustration. I know the BX rules with an intimacy of an old lover; the shine of novelty has long worn off, but in its place a deeper and more honest understanding blooms. The obtuse mechanics, the references to spells that don't exist, the example of play that violates the rules set out not a few pages earlier, the inconsistent and nebulous phrasing throughout—no longer are these issues off-putting but instead part of the indelible whole. 

Of course, I am but a man. I too have made modifications to the game over the years to suit my preferences and those of my table. I borrow liberally from OD&D, the "truest" instantiation of the game, and AD&D, whose DMG demands talmudic study in exchange for great wisdom. I lift a house rule here and there and make my own when the need arises. I drink deeply from the well of collective wisdom fed by OSR-heads from across the ages. I've said elsewhere and I maintain that the slot encumbrance system in Carcass Crawler #2 is the closest to the platonic ideal of encumbrance systems I ever care to get. 

But all that is done not because I wish the game be something it's not, but because I want it to be what it is more readily. 

What differentiates a change that makes the game something it's not vs. one that keeps it what it is? What the game, the pastiche of old school D&D systems and derived games, "is" is different for everyone. But one thing that holds true is the game invites work. 

A number of posts crossed my desk recently that praise rolling your sleeves up and embracing the work of GMing. Do legwork, chew your own damn food, eat the book, and while you're at it stop writing like a robot! These are all focused on different subjects and make different arguments but they trace the same idea: working through a task grants you better understanding and greater discovery than using shortcuts. Shortcuts have their place, but the work is often worth it. 

I contend that rules which obviate tracking, be they usage dice, overloaded encounter rolls, abstract distance, freeform magic, and everything else that follows the same tack, are in same broad category of "shortcut design." 

Now the point of critical nuance: Shortcuts, whether generators, bullet points, or simplified mechanics, are not by their nature bad, and crunchy text-heavy work-filled material is not by its nature good. These are value neutral tools the writer-designer-GM may draw upon to suit the dictates of taste and demands of the project.

But one must acknowledge what is lost with such shortcuts. 

You are a GM for OSR/NSR/DIY D&D-style games. You are MASTER of the game. When you do the work and track the game state faithfully, you have every detail of the world at your disposal. Your creation exists in its own right, yet you know everything about it you need to. And when the rules are stretched and the limits of game-reality tested, you know exactly where best to let them yield. Because you are the Master. 

When you shirk your responsibility for sake of ease, you become a subject of the system. The conveniences free you from the need to track, yes. But you are no longer master of the game world. It is obscured to you by a fog of uncertainty. When you need solid assurance of when and where things are, as inevitably you will, the game world will not tell you. You haven't been listening. You have only yourself, and so you must hand-wave, make-up, GM-fiat an answer. And in those moments the game world ceases to exist, and it's just you, making a decision in front of the players at the table. And if you decide something difficult the players will think you unfair and if you decide something easy they will think you are letting them off. 

The same concept holds true for players. 

Look to the Blorb Principles. Specifically the principle of Diegetical Mechanics. Specifically, this one part:

Not every genre is about meticulous inventory—you can run an office romantic drama without knowing exactly how many staplers are on every desk—but for situations when gear is important, it’s one of the few moments where what the player should be caring about matches with what the character should be caring about.

The same is true generally for diegetical mechanics. You get transported to the game world.

Replace gear with movement speed, torch duration, how many arrows you have in your quiver. All these things are useful to know because all these things are relevant to the game. When it's time to rest, your torch is sputtering, and you hear a wandering monster shambling down the hall, you know your character is in the shit because you are in the shit. And you know when you use your last arrow it's because you decided to, just like you decided to use each and every one before that. It was you who decided and not some dice. 

Thursday, February 26, 2026

Encounter Motives Over Encounter Activities

About month ago I made a Bluesky thread (follow me) some people found useful, and I wanted to share it here. This isn't me cannibalizing my thoughts across platforms. This is an adaptation.

A lot of people conceptualize random encounters as the party encountering the monsters, but they make more sense the other way: the monsters encounter the party. Encounter activity tables/"what are these monsters doing" lists can be helpful tools in certain situations, but they represent a way of viewing random encounters that works against how wandering monsters function best in the game. 

Arnold K's seminal "WTF are these goblins doing?" table is the clearest and probably most popular example of what I'm getting at. 

This table works well for a number of reasons. 

  1. It conveys a large amount of information about goblins and their lifestyle, habits, and behavior in a condensed form. Even without making explicit use of the table, it gives a GM a strong enough impression of what goblins are like that they can easily make them come to life at the table.
  2. It allows repeat encounters to be distinct from one another. 
  3. It gives goblins depth. If you run into a goblin in the middle of something it makes them seem like a living creature instead of a knife tied to a bag of hit points. 

Nowadays its even common to bake activities in to the encounter table itself. "2d6 goblins playing kiss the blowfish" is more exciting than "2d6 goblins." And you get two of the three benefits above without having to rely on a whole other table. 

But, despite these benefits, monster activities such as these have a number of downsides. 

First, they imply the monsters are stationary and not wandering. 

Monsters hang out in a hallways, sure, but stationary activities are generally the purview of room encounters—what you key when you're prepping a dungeon. Random encounters can happen anywhere, even when the players themselves are stationary. Think about what happens if a random encounter is rolled while the PCs are in an empty room. The monsters are the ones on the move, so they're not going to be engaged in activities like "playing knucklebones" or "repairing a trap." This is why, traditionally, random encounters are rolled on a "wandering monsters" table.

Additionally, such encounter activities imply the PCs are walking in on a group of monsters in the middle of something. 

While surprise is a possibility, it's not guaranteed for every encounter. Some games even deny the possibility that monsters can be surprised by a party carrying blazing torches through the inky darkness of the underworld. 


Above is from OSE, below is OD&D Vol. 3: THE UNDERWORLD & WILDERNESS ADVENTURES

Since in most circumstances monsters are aware of the party's presence, it's reasonable to assume they'd have stopped what their doing by the time the party sees them. 

Most important, encounter activities don't tell you WHY monsters are interested in the PCs. If encountered monsters are preoccupied with something else, careful players have little reason to engage with them, and it's harder to contrive a reason for why monsters should care. 

When that happens, encounters run the risk of becoming just the DM describing monsters engaged in an activity and then the players going "ok cool, let's move on."

Saying "just ignore nonsensical results!" doesn't work here. If a tool assumes we will be regularly ignoring what the dice tell us to do (at the table, specifically; I contend prep is different), we could be using a better tool. 

Are these kinds of encounter activities always bad? Absolutely not. But there's something else we can use to add color to random encounters.

Wandering monsters already have an activity baked in (wandering, of course), but we can add more dimension by determining their MOTIVE. The expanded reaction table that's been floating around for a while is a good example of what I mean. A monster's needs inform the encounter.

Please tell me if you know who made this

Determining wandering monsters' motive doesn't just tell you why they're wandering, it—crucially—tells you what they want from the PCs, and how they'll go about getting it. That's a lot of bang for your buck! 

Ditto above

When designing encounters, think about activities that can answer these two questions:

1. Why are these monsters wandering?

2. What would these monsters want with the PCs? 

These questions don't need to be elaborate answers. You don't have to be particularly clever or creative when coming up with monster motives. In fact, simpler answers may be better because the players catch on faster. 

"Looking for food," "guarding territory," "hunting for treasure" are all suitable motives. Acclaimed Canadian Levi Kornelsen points out: "In human complexes where work is done, a *huge* amount of the time, what wandering humans are doing in the halls is moving things around. Food, waste, furniture (it me!), bodies, materials, messages. Any hive of activity is constantly shuffling stuff around." 

Not only do motives give immediate explanation for what monsters are doing and why, they tell you what kinds of decisions they would make when encountering the party. 

Friday, January 23, 2026

Vivid Worlds Will Kill You


The question “How do I make a fantasy setting feel real?” is one people never really ever stop grappling with. Especially in games.

There is a lot of good input on this topic: have things change over time, create interactions between aspects of the world that don’t involve the players, and borrow judiciously from the real world, which of course everyone has been told is stranger than fiction. 

 

In old school D&D, making an environment feel real is a solved issue, as long as the environment is a dungeon or can be navigated using the dungeon exploration rules. Movement speeds, 10-minute turns, and random encounter procedures are like the enzymes that turn grid-paper maps and sparse room keys into vivid, realized locales—it’s the magic trick that gets so many people hooked on the OSR. 


But dungeons aren’t the same as full settings, and the deeper layers of abstraction used to map and explore an overworld make it harder to bring outdoor environments to life. This is especially the case with imagined environments that have only loose connection to the real world. 


Two non-game works that prominently feature settings of particular vividness: Scavengers Reign, the 2023 sci-fi HBO show known by many of you to be a rare mainstream cultural product inspired by Jean Giraud that has merit beyond just being inspired by Jean Giraud, and Fantastic Planet, a 1973 French and Czech animated film that most of you probably first watched stoned and/or in college.  


If you’ve seen both you probably came to the same conclusion I did, that the latter almost definitely informed the former, at least in terms of setting: they both take place on alien worlds where the worlds themselves, specifically the interactions between organisms and their environment, are more distinctive and memorable than the plots and characters. 


In watching Scavengers Reign when it was airing, and then rewatching Fantastic Planet more recently, I kept asking myself why these settings worked so well. Sure, the camera lingered on weird creatures and landscapes long enough to fix themselves in you mind, but the same can be said for, say, the Star Wars sequel trilogy but not nearly to the same effect.


It turns out it's not the settings themselves but the kinds of stories they support. Scavengers Reign and Fantastic Planet are both survival narratives, and it’s specifically the survival aspect that makes the ecology of the setting hit harder. 


In other words, each work uses the context of survival as a framework upon which elaborate, imaginative settings are built; the settings convey meaning by way of ecological interactions. Because survival fiction inextricably ties plot to the basic facts of the environment, the genre conventions are well-suited to bring to life fantasy environments in ways no other genre can quite accomplish.  


Let’s take a look at how. 


Scavengers Reign




Scavengers Reign follows survivors in the far future shipwrecked on an alien world. When the show begins, separate groups of survivors are eking out meager existence on the planet Vesta after their ship, the Demeter 227, experiences an ambiguous disaster. In the first episode, a pair of survivors activate the Demeter’s emergency landing protocol, and the disparate survivors witness what remains of the craft slowly make its way to the planet's surface. Each survivor decides to journey to the wreckage, and their adventures through lush environments make up the substance of the show.


Much of the series is spent on the complexity of interrelationships within Vesta’s ecosystems. Character moments and plot beats are interspersed with brief scenes of symbiosis, parasitism, and predation, portrayed in such a way as to highlight the rationality of flora and fauna’s adaptations while underscoring the alienness of the environment. 


In one episode, a brief montage shows the lifecycle of a species of a sort of tree. It begins with a hypodermic tendril extracting DNA from an unsuspecting herd creature, then the gestation of a vegetal simulacrum in a hanging birthing sac, which joins up with the herd only to detonate in an explosion of spore-like seedlings, producing a new stand of trees fed by the bodies of the exploded herd. All of this is shown as lead up to a main character getting stuck by the hypodermic tendril and later a tense scene where his traveling companion is confronted by his plant clone. 



While much of the ecology the characters encounter is incredibly dangerous in horrifying and elaborate ways, the show makes explicit that not all flora and fauna pose a direct threat. Some instances depict the environment as wondrous and even beneficial to the characters’ survival. In one scene, a character suffering from a skin disease seeks respite in a pool of water. Suddenly, the viewer sees a pack of dark fish approach from the depths, and there’s an “oh shit” moment where you expect they may attack. But the tension is immediately resolved once the fish begin harmlessly nibbling at the infected flesh, assuaging the character’s ailment. 

This tension around what is and isn’t a threat is central to the flow of the narrative, which simply wouldn’t work if everything was overtly dangerous. The point is not that Vesta is dangerous but that it is alien—everything has its own logic, which can only be discovered through observation and experimentation. 

This experimentation and observation is the key to every character’s survival, which they go about in different ways: each must adapt to the environment by learning how they may integrate themselves into the ecosystem—figuratively for the most part, as most characters navigate various hazards, but literally in the case of one character who physically and mentally merges with a psychic predator, and also literally in the case of a robot who experiences a strange one-ness with the planet after mysterious golden mold integrates with their circuitry. Those that fail to adapt all perish.  


More importantly, this experimentation and observation in a survival context is key to making the world feel vivid and distinctive. If the alien world was a setting for a different sort of story to take place, say like Pandora in the first Avatar film, Vesta might be remembered only as a series of lush backdrops with maybe a familiar merchandise-friendly animal popping up here and there, as opposed to the layered, puzzle-box ecosystem it is given the space to be. The workings of the planet are not set dressing, they're the source of conflict and driver of change in the narrative.


Fantastic Planet


As mentioned above, immediately noticeable to anyone familiar with Scavengers Reign and Fantastic Planet, is their shared fixation on showing the natural workings of their respective alien ecologies. 


Fantastic Planet takes place on an alien world dominated by a race of giant blue humanoids called Draags. Human beings, brought from Earth some time in the indefinite past, are treated as animals and sometimes kept as pets. The story follows a human pet who escapes his home and joins a community of wild humans who eventually rise up against the Draags, voyage to the “fantastic planet” orbiting the Draag world, and win freedom for all mankind. 


Unlike the world of Scavengers Reign, with its sort of naturalistic indifference, the world of Fantastic Planet is overtly hostile. The sparse, brutal locales of the film’s setting are home to nightmarish flora and fauna, each designed to feel as cruel and inhospitable as possible. They clamp, whip, and slice senselessly as fragile humans scurry through the narrative. 


One scene that’s particularly illustrative of this hostility: the protagonist and another human are making their way through some tangled overgrowth. Looming above is some sort of plant or creature that looks like a pumpkin-shaped head sporting a long branching nose supported on several stalks within an organic cage. A bird creature flaps toward the head and lands on one of the nose-branches. The branches then close around the bird, shake it violently, and then toss it to the ground where the camera lingers on dozens of other bird corpses littered about. I clipped the scene and included it here because it's too good to describe with just words.



The lingering on the corpses subtly demonstrates that Fantastic Planet should be understood as a film about its setting, with the plot simply there to justify moving from one ecological scene to another. Whereas in Scavengers Reign human stories are told through how survivors interact with alien ecologies, the alien organisms and bizarre natural scenes cover far more of what Fantastic Planet is as a work of art than the plot or characters.


Fantastic Planet establishes itself as a survival story upon which such a distinctive, resonant setting is built through how it features humanity in relation to the environment. Human characters are depicted as tiny ants against harsh barren landscapes, fragile as paper dolls when they are pulled and plucked by curious Draags or hungry predators. This use of scale and severity highlights the hostility of the world, amplifying to a grotesque degree what is at bottom a very basic story about how humans use ingenuity to overcome our status as squishy subjects in a dangerous world. 


What else? (SURPRISE it's Hundreds of Beavers)



A third work, much different from the previous two, brings home the point. 


The 2022 slapstick comedy Hundreds of Beavers represents a third approach to worldbuilding through survival. The film follows Jean Kayak, an applejack brewer whose life is upended after beavers destroy his home and farm. Jean finds himself alone and naked in the wintry wilderness, where over the course of the film he develops the skills and wherewithal to become a legendary trapper.


The film differs from the previous two examples as Hundreds of Beavers take place not on an alien world but right here on Earth, though a black-and-white comedified version. The looney-tunes logic is essentially as novel to Jean as it is to the viewer, who despite inhabiting the setting prior to the events of the film still must learn the workings of the environment through observation and trial and error.  It is exactly this sort of logic that establishes the character of the setting, and that Jean exploits to go from incompetent to a master of his world.



Much of the film's comedy and worldbuilding comes from introducing a phenomenon, such as a bird that attacks Jean early in the movie, prompted by him whistling when a nest full of eggs is within reach; reintroducing the phenomenon in a new context, such as when Jean, later in the film, is attacked by the bird who appears from seemingly nowhere when he makes the same whistle in an unrelated circumstance; and then reinterpreting the phenomenon into an exploitable facet of the world, such as when Jean, late in the movie, puts his distinctive hat on an unsuspecting target and then issues the now-familiar whistle, summoning the bird to attack the disguised victim. The bird example is only one instance of many of these phenomena constantly being iterated upon and intersecting in novel ways. 


Though Hundreds of Beavers has different aims as a work of art and as a speculative setting than Scavengers Reign and Fantastic Planet, the ecology is foregrounded in the same way. The work is not as focused on the environment as such, rather on the comical interactions between Jean and the wilderness’s inhabitants, but the way these interactions are mediated is through a similarly “alien” set of rules and sideways rationalities. In this way, Hundreds of Beavers shares a common thread with Scavengers Reign and Fantastic Planet in how they both focus on people reduced to a primitive state, Scavengers Reign in particular how survival is secured through observation and experimentation with the local ecology and Fantastic Planet with protagonists’ drive to transcend through knowledge their circumstances as subject to the whims of a world they are not suited for. 


Putting this to use

These three survival stories tells us what any OSR person already knows, which is that it is the constraints inherent to an environment that makes the environment feel vivid. For dungeons we already have darkness, traps, stuck doors, and the like, but for some reason it has been much more difficult to apply these same principles to overworked exploration. 

The closest I've seen anyone come to this is Ms. Screwhead with the excellent laws of the land. 

By putting difficulty first, we establish impediments to survival which in turn help players build meaningful relationships with the setting. 

A good rule of thumb for challenging regions is that they should have clear answers to about two or three of these questions. Any more and the area risks becoming prohibitively difficult (which is not always a problem but something to keep in mind).
  1. Why is resting is difficult?
  2. Why is finding food is difficult?
  3. Why is travel difficult?
  4. Why is not getting lost is difficult?
  5. Why is fighting difficult?
  6. Why transporting cumbersome goods or treasure is difficult?
Instead of trying to invent a new system to generate survival ecosystems, I'll lay out a pair of lists of biotic and abiotic factors in an ecosystem with baked-in difficulty. Consider these as levers to pull to answer the above questions. 

Biotic factors
  1. Large territorial predators
  2. Coordinated pack hunters
  3. Camouflage or mimicking predators
  4. Mesopredators or prey with deterring, fear-inducing, or hypnotic self-defense mechanisms
  5. Habitat-modifying (i.e. burrowing, dam-building, etc.) creatures
  6. Behavior-altering parasites or pathogen vectors
  7. Swarming insects
  8. Plants with harmful self-defense mechanisms
  9. Carnivorous or trapping plants
  10. Highly active decomposers
Abiotic factors (you probably want no more than two of these per region)
  1. Extreme temperature (intense heat or cold, sudden swings, microclimate pockets)
  2. Extreme wind (gales, tornadoes, downbursts) 
  3. High water variability (drought, flash floods, ephemeral rivers)
  4. High terrain instability (tremors, rockslides, fissures)
  5. Toxic or corroding chemicals (hazardous soil minerals, acid pools)
  6. Combustion (wild fires, flammable peat)
  7. Low visibility (haze, fog)
  8. High verticality (cliffs, overhangs, ravines, sinkholes)
  9. Anomalous weather (icicle-knife hail, magnet storms, rain of frogs)
  10. Harmful air (poison smog, spores)
As a fun exercise, you can quickly hack together a rudimentary system of ecological relationships by explaining adaptations the biotic factors have as a response to each other and the abiotic factor. Perhaps in the future I'll make this a more robust and usable tool.

Here's an example: 
I rolled 9 and 2 for biotic factors and 8 for an abiotic factor: 
  • Carnivorous plant
  • Pack hunter
  • High verticality
Specific adaptation the carnivorous plant has to living in a region with high verticality: 
Long, corded tendrils that dangle over ledges, contract when agitated. Unsuspecting creatures are constricted and slowly pulled up to the plant to be consumed for nutrients. 
Specific adaptation the coordinated pack hunter has to surviving in spite of the carnivorous plant:
Bipedal hunting lizards with two edged spines protruding scissor-like from their tails. Use their spines to shear through the tendrils otherwise too thick to claw or chew apart. 

You can layer in more biotic and abiotic factors as you please. 


Thursday, October 31, 2024

1, 10, or 1000000

 I’ve been kicking around a design rule recently I’m calling “1, 10, or 1000000.” The idea is that when you’re determining how prevalent something should be in your game there should either be one of them, 10 of them, or a million. 

Maybe not exactly those numbers. More accurately, if you’re thinking about how prevalent something should be in the campaign, any given thing should either be unique, part of a small coherent grouping, or common if not ubiquitous. What this means specifically varies from thing to thing so here are some examples:

Dragons

There is one dragon. Maybe not the only dragon in the entire game world, but for the purposes of the campaign there is only the one. This will likely be the most dragon-y dragon a DM could muster. The players might encounter it in passing or hear about it from time to time as they progress but they wouldn’t hope to have any chance of slaying it (or convincing it to be their ally, subduing it, etc.) until late in the game. The dragon is probably tied to the history of the setting or has some significant influence on the current circumstances. There’s only one dragon, so it has to count. 

There are 10 dragons. They all know each other, and people know about them—if not all then enough to know that there are several dragons in the area. Each dragon has their own domain, goals, tastes, and their own of opinions of one another. Each dragon probably has a couple unique features in addition to the normal dragon stuff that make them distinct both from the other dragons and the stereotypical “fantasy dragon” that exists in the mind of the players. Some of the dragons are mean, some are nice, all are menacing yet for different reasons. 

There are 1000000 dragons. They’re everywhere, from the tallest mountains to the depths of the sea. In every cave there dwells a dragon, in every forest they stalk and prey. Some rule city states, others hide in abandoned cellars. They come in all shapes, sizes, and temperaments. This is probably the baseline monster the PCs will be dealing with throughout the campaign.

Sages

There is one sage. She lives somewhere rather inconvenient to get to and it takes at least a session worth of adventuring to find her for the first time. Being the only sage, she’s knowledgeable on just about everything worth asking about, though she exacts a steep price for her services. She's probably an important figure in the setting despite being a recluse. A possible quest for the PCs would be if a powerful political leader tasks them to bribe her so that she gives false info to his adversaries.  

There are 10 sages. They are the current members of a secret order that’s been around for centuries. They’re scattered all over the map, some in settlements, some in the wilderness, some traveling from place to place. In addition to their respective areas of knowledge each one’s got a “schtick:” one’s the mad scientist who wants to do experiments on the PCs, one’s the fogey hermit who might or might not be a badass kung fu master, one’s the eccentric inventor that always has stuff blowing up in his face, and maybe one is like a talking cat or a sentient ooze or something. They definitely have a bunch of secret signs and rites. If the player need information on a given subject and none of the sages they are buddies with know about it, they would tell them who the right sage is to look for and it would be a whole thing like “go to this distant barbarian village and show the chief this special sign and he will lead you to a clearing where in the light of the moon Umru the Clever will appear on the back of a three-horned rhino. At first he will refuse to help you but ask him three times and he will tell you what you seek to know.”  

There are 1000000 sages. You can find one in just about every town, next to the blacksmith’s or the local tavern. They’re on the wilderness encounter table and maybe the dungeon one too, at least for the earlier levels. On the spectrum of background character to fully fleshed out NPC, sages lean toward the former, along with shopkeepers and city guards. Using a sage would be a pretty streamlined process—you pay them some money and they have a percentile chance of answering your question. High level PCs can hire out sages just like any other kind of specialist to have on staff in their stronghold. 

Races

There is one race: the human ra- For the purposes of this kind of campaign there are humans and then everything else. If there are elves and dwarves and halflings they’d be so minor they aren’t relevant to the campaign setting (so you won’t be hanging out in the elf kingdom or helping the dwarves in their war effort against the goblins). Humanoids like orcs and gnolls are soulless monsters in the same category as chimeras and vampires and other things that want you dead. 

There are 10 races. Humans might be the one the campaign is centered around, but demihumans, monstrous humanoids, and a handful of other sapient creatures have a significant presence in the campaign setting. Some are playable, definitely more than one, but probably not all. Within each population is probably a decent amount of variation—there’s more than one type of elf, dwarf, and so on. Each race has at least vaguely defined customs and characteristics that distinguish them mechanically as well as narratively. For instance, if orcs of different tribes encounter each other they may need to save or immediately turn hostile. There may be another, separate intelligent species in a specific adventure location or two, but the point is if you have the four basic races and lizardmen, bird people, and hobgoblins, then the players aren’t going to be regularly running into bugbears, kobolds, and gnomes on their adventures.  


There are 1000000 races. Everything and the kitchen sink. There’s probably a nice meaty d20 list of races to roll on for character creation and implied even more in the game world. One session the players might be fighting the axolotl-men, the next they might be trying to impress the king of the coatimundi-men, the next they’re stealing treasure from the red-lipped-batfish-men. Here, races are treated less as distinct species and more as distinct people-groups. There’s almost certainly going to be that ren-faire quality some settings have where when you go to the city you’re greeted by a minotaur guard as a family of myconids walk by.

Magic items.

There is (around) one magic item (per player). In this kind of game finding a magic item is a huge, campaign-defining moment. Any magic item that shows up would be an incredible differentiator for the party and also potentially the mcguffin around which an entire adventure is centered. 

There are 10 magic items. Maybe in this circumstance there are 10 of a certain major kind (10 swords, 10 pieces of enchanted jewelry) that have similar provenance and make up the main focus as far as magical treasure is concerned, with other magic items being largely auxiliary. Each item would have one or several open-ended qualities that make them broadly useful while also having some definite drawbacks to limit their utility. Perhaps the drawbacks of one can be mitigated by another, creating a sense of momentum as the players acquire them. The ten magic items could make up the premise of the campaign—"gather each segment of the rod of seven parts"—or they could just be more incidental marks of distinction—"be wary, for the warlord you oppose is said to wield one of the 12 legendary demon blades." The ten magic items don’t also have to have the same origin or be the same kind of object, but they ought to be at least distinguishable as in the same class as one another. Patrick Stuart’s proposed World of 100 Wonders is an example of this kind of setup. 

There are 1000000 magic items. Most are minor, with specific and limited functions that make them handy to have around but not totally gamebreaking. As the PCs explore and find more items it would be like they’re filling out their utility belts, getting more tools to handle incrementally greater challenges and to facilitate new approaches. A lot of these items would probably be consumable like potions or can only be used a set number of times like wands. I’ve never played Numenera but I think it does something like this with cyphers.  

Dungeons

There is one dungeon. The mega one. This is a classic-style dungeon big enough to accommodate an entire campaign. This is where the DM crams every one of their dungeony ideas. There are levels, sublevels, secret levels, and enough interconnectivity between them to make the dungeon less a thing to get to the end of and more an open environment to explore and manipulate. 

There are 10 dungeons. This is like Legend of Zelda, where each dungeon has some motifs that show up in the puzzles and traps and monsters. Despite the preponderance of dungeons in D&D games I feel this is a rather underutilized concept: a set number of dungeons from the outset, each distinctly themed, where in one you’d find an item or a clue that would help you circumvent an obstacle in another. This kind of game might also represent an inversion of the BX game play progression that starts into players in the dungeon until they get strong enough to explore the wilderness—here players may begin the game with wilderness exploration, with the goal of making it to a dungeon, and then progress as far as they can until they get bored or hit roadblock, and then explore the overworld again until they find another dungeon. 


There are 1000000 dungeons. Everything the players that isn’t exploring dungeons is either moving between dungeons, coming back to town from a dungeon, or setting out to go to a dungeon. Aside from a couple prepared ones, the dungeons in this campaign would likely be procedurally generated on an as-needed basis; players enter a new hex, dice determine they find a dungeon, and then the DM pulls out the geomorphs and the party is on their way. The dungeons would probably be pretty short, punchy, and dense, to prevent them from getting stale and keep the players going through them at a decent clip. 

Further elaboration

  • Truth be told, in most circumstances I can think of 10 is probably too many of a thing to accommodate in one campaign. Five (+ or - 2 of course) is a much more workable number. But I went with 10 to keep it a consistent powers of 10 thing. 
  • If it’s not already clear, the number does not always need to refer to the literal number of people or things—giving knights a 1 could mean there is 1 knight in your campaign or 1 knightly order. 10 could also refer to a knightly order of 10 knights—the difference is that a “1” knightly order would have a strong theme that carries over to every member, but one knight might not be that different than the other. On the other hand in a “10” knightly order each knight is their own character with their own traits and personalities. There might be overlap between the knights to reflect the theme of the knightly order, but each member would reflect the theme in their own way (so if it was an order of space knights, one might have a laser sword and a suit of robot armor, one might be like an astrologer-mystic, one might be a void guy who wears black and doesn’t speak, and so on).
  • I use the term “campaign setting” here a lot, which I mean to refer to the specific locale that the campaign occupies—it could be the entire planet, or it could just be a specific region. If all or most of your campaign takes place within the confines of a 12x12 hex map, that’s the campaign setting regardless of what exists elsewhere in that fantasy world. A thing that you assign a 1 to for your campaign could be much more common elsewhere in the game world, but for the sake of your campaign specifically there is only one. 

What this solves

Every now and then when I’m coming up with stuff for the campaign I struggle to establish how much weight a concept ought to have. Usually I sort of get attached to one approach but then don’t want to close the possibility of a different approach and then I end up with a noncommittal in between that lacks any kind of satisfaction, so I scrap it all and start over. 

The 1, 10, or 1000000 rule is a nice little creative constraint to bounce off of. It provides a concrete metric of prevalence so there's no more having to sort through competing visions for an ambiguous desired outcome, that being the sort of attention I want something to have in the campaign. 

If I, say, want a lot of different kinds of mercenaries in my game but I’m also mostly just excited about one specific idea I have for a mercenary band, I would have once had that mercenary band be the most fully fleshed out and only vaguely gesture at the existence of other mercenary armies through random encounters and rumors the players may not even pay attention to. The 1, 10, or 1000000 rule resolves this by dictating that mercenary bands should either be ubiquitous enough that any distinction is no more than window dressing, there should be a defined amount of different mercenary bands in the area, or there should just be the one band that about every mercenary in the campaign belongs to. Each is a valid course, and more importantly they do away with the ambiguity that exists between my concept for the mercenary band and how mercenaries actually show up in the campaign. 

Ultimately, the rule is for clarity and decisiveness. Using it lets each choice feel intentional.

It might go without saying but this rule isn't applicable to every circumstance. Sometimes it's fine to have a group of things somewhere in the middle of 1 and 10 or 10 and 1000000. Traps in a dungeon, for instance—the should be prevalent but not everywhere, they don't need to be put into a categorizable, and there shouldn't just be one trap or kind of trap unless your dungeons really small. 

So like most rules of thumb, it's best to use when you get stuck or want to try a new approach.